Is AI search optimisation different from SEO?
Google's own guidance says optimising for generative AI search is still SEO. Where that holds, and where the layer on top behaves differently.
By Kuraib AliPublished Updated 9 min read
Google is right about the system underneath. The ranking system behind AI Overviews and AI Mode is the same one that ranks regular search results, so most technical SEO fundamentals still apply. But the layer built on top of that system, the one that decides what gets quoted, summarised and cited in an AI answer, behaves differently. Specific content choices measurably change your odds of showing up there.
What did Google say?
In May 2026, Google Search Central published its first official guide to optimising for generative AI features in Search. The core message: AI Overviews and AI Mode are built on Google's existing Search ranking and quality systems, not a separate one. The guide goes further than a general statement. It specifically tells site owners they don't need new markup for AI features, that there's no dedicated schema.org type for showing up in an AI Overview, and that splitting content into rigid segments for easier AI parsing isn't something Google's systems require.
That last point matters because it's where a lot of paid answer engine optimisation (AEO) and generative engine optimisation (GEO) advice diverges from what Google itself is asking for. Search Engine Journal's coverage of the guide put it plainly: this is still SEO.
The scepticism isn't coming from nowhere
Google isn't the only one making this argument. Forrester's research on SEO's shifting role in marketing describes AEO as significantly, but not fundamentally, different from SEO, a useful framing because it doesn't dismiss the differences, it just refuses to call them a new discipline. CMSWire has reported on SEO professionals watching organic traffic flatten or drop while being sold AEO retainers with no clear measurement attached, and the piece is blunt about vendors overselling what those retainers change.
Then there's llms.txt, probably the single most oversold tactic in this space. John Mueller has compared it to the old keywords meta tag: something site owners add because it feels like it should matter, not because any evidence says it does. Gary Illyes has said the same at a Search Central event: Google doesn't use it and has no plans to. An Ahrefs analysis of 137,000 sites found that 97% of published llms.txt files were never fetched by anything in a full month. If a tactic doesn't move the system it's supposedly optimising for, it isn't optimisation. It's a checkbox.
Google's own guide says creating an llms.txt file "will neither harm nor help" your visibility in Google Search, because Google Search ignores it. Other platforms may read it, but the Ahrefs data above shows how little the files are requested in practice. It isn't a tactic worth building a strategy around.
Where does the still-SEO framing fall short?
Here's where I think the flat nothing-has-changed reading goes too far. A 2024 study by Aggarwal et al. (the first version listed researchers from Princeton, Georgia Tech, the Allen Institute for AI and IIT Delhi; the current version lists IIT Delhi, Princeton and independent researchers), formalised as Generative Engine Optimization at KDD 2024, tested which content changes moved visibility inside AI-generated answers. Adding citations to sources, direct quotations, and specific statistics each produced meaningful gains on their visibility metric, in the range of 30 to 41 per cent. Keyword density, the classic SEO lever, did almost nothing in the same tests.
That's not a contradiction of Google's guidance. Ranking and being selected for a generated answer aren't the same event. A page can rank well under ordinary Search signals and still lose out to a competitor's page when an AI system is choosing what to quote, because the AI is applying a second layer of judgement on top of ranking: is this passage citable, specific, and attributable. That second layer rewards different things than the ranking layer does, even while running on the ranking layer's output.
There's a second data point. In an August 2025 study of 75,000 brands, Ahrefs ran a Spearman correlation between a range of brand and site metrics and how often each brand appeared in Google AI Overviews. Web mentions came out at roughly 0.664, well ahead of backlinks at 0.218, the metric classic SEO has spent two decades optimising for. Ahrefs' own write-up flags that correlation isn't causation, and that even the strongest of these relationships is only moderate on the Spearman scale. So this is evidence to weigh, not proof of a new ranking factor. Still, if the pattern holds, it suggests the thing best predicting whether you get cited by an AI system isn't the thing that's predicted rankings for years. Same underlying search index, different selection criteria sitting on top of it.
And the overlap between ranking and being cited is far from complete, though the firms measuring it don't agree on the size. An Ahrefs study published in March 2026, covering 863,000 keyword search engine results pages (SERPs) and about 4 million AI Overview citations, found that 37.9% of citations came from a query's top-10 organic results. Ahrefs' July 2025 figure of 76% counted only the top three citations per Overview and used older parsing, so the two aren't like for like; Ahrefs itself reads the drop as Google drawing more on fan-out searches. BrightEdge has reported a lower figure, about 17% of citations from top-10 pages, using its own panel and methodology. The studies disagree sharply on the exact number. There is no settled figure anyone can quote with confidence, only a consistent finding that many cited pages don't rank in the top ten. Ranking well is clearly still necessary. It isn't sufficient on its own.
How is measuring AI-search visibility different from SEO rank tracking?
This is where the practical, day-to-day difference shows up most, and it's mostly a tooling and methodology problem rather than a strategy one. A traditional rank tracker checks a fixed keyword against a specific search engine and location, and returns a position: page one, spot four, done. That works because a Google SERP for a given query and location is, for practical purposes, the same list of results for everyone checking it at that moment.
AI answers don't behave that way. Ask the same prompt of the same AI system twice and the wording, the sources cited, and sometimes whether a brand gets mentioned at all can vary between runs, since generative answers aren't pulled from one static, rankable list the way a SERP is. That single fact is why AI-visibility tools built for this (Frase, Peec AI, and similar platforms among them) don't report a "position." They instead run a defined set of representative prompts against one or more AI systems repeatedly, then report how often a brand, domain, or specific page shows up in the response, cited as a source, or mentioned by name, across that sample. That's usually described as a share-of-voice or citation-frequency metric rather than a rank.
Three practical consequences follow from that difference:
- Sample size matters more than it did for rank tracking. One prompt run once tells you almost nothing, because a single answer can vary. Visibility figures only become meaningful once measured across a meaningful set of prompts, run repeatedly over time.
- "Which platform" is now a real variable. ChatGPT, Perplexity, Google AI Mode, and Copilot don't necessarily cite the same sources for the same question, so a visibility number from one platform doesn't transfer to another the way a Google ranking roughly used to predict Bing performance.
- Citation and mention are different events worth tracking separately. Some tools distinguish a brand being named in passing from a specific page being cited as a source with a link. The second is closer to what a backlink used to represent; the first is closer to a brand-awareness signal that ordinary SEO reporting never had a direct equivalent for.
None of this replaces rank tracking. It sits alongside it, measuring a different event with a different method. The "just SEO" framing is right about the underlying system, but it undersells how differently the two now have to be measured.
Where this leaves you
Google is right that there's no separate ranking system to build for, no special schema, no file format that delivers AI visibility on its own. Anyone selling AEO or GEO as an entirely new technical discipline, with its own infrastructure requirements, is selling something Google's own documentation contradicts.
But the selection layer sitting on top of ranking, the part deciding what gets quoted once a page has already earned its place in the index, does appear to reward specific, citable, source-backed writing over the kind of thin, keyword-led content that used to be enough to rank. That's not a new discipline. It's closer to old-fashioned editorial rigour mattering again, just measured by a different system than backlinks, and increasingly measured with different tools too.
Practically, that means: keep doing real technical SEO, because it's still the entry ticket. Don't buy llms.txt or AI-specific schema as a fix for a visibility problem Google has explicitly said neither one solves. Do check whether your content is specific, sourced and quotable enough for an AI system to pick it to cite, because that appears to be where the competition has moved. And measuring it now takes a different kind of tool from the rank tracker already on your desk.
None of this is guaranteed to change your citation rate or your rankings. Nobody can promise that, and anyone who does is the exact problem this piece is about. What follows from here is testing it directly rather than taking anyone's word for it, including the sources cited above.
New to these terms? See AEO, GEO and SEO: what each term means. For the crawler-access side of this argument, see do AI crawlers read your site.
Frequently asked questions
Do I need a completely separate strategy for AI search versus Google Search?
No. The underlying ranking and indexing requirements are the same system, so ordinary technical SEO remains the entry ticket for both. What differs is a secondary selection layer that decides what gets quoted in an AI answer, which rewards specific, sourced, quotable writing more than keyword optimisation does.
Is llms.txt worth implementing?
For Google specifically, no. Google's own staff have said it isn't used and there are no plans to change that. Ahrefs' June 2026 study of 137,210 domains found that 97% of llms.txt files got no requests at all in the month it measured, so there is little sign of meaningful use by other platforms either.
Can I use my existing SEO rank tracker to measure AI search visibility?
Not directly. A rank tracker reports a fixed position for a query at a point in time. AI-visibility tracking instead runs a set of representative prompts against one or more AI systems repeatedly and measures how often a brand or page gets mentioned or cited, because AI answers aren't a stable, single ranked list the way a search engine results page (SERP) is.